Nijora InScientology was founded by L. There are also problems with qntipsiquiatria standard diagnostic criteria in different countries, cultures, genders or ethnic groups. Social workhumanistic or existentialist therapies, family therapycounseling and self-help and clinical psychology developed and sometimes opposed psychiatry. The first widespread challenge to the prevailing medical approach in Western countries occurred in the late 18th century. Mentally ill people are essentially no more prone to violence than sane individuals, despite Hollywood and other media portrayals to the contrary.
|Published (Last):||6 June 2010|
|PDF File Size:||14.83 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||13.44 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Precursors[ edit ] The first widespread challenge to the prevailing medical approach in Western countries occurred in the late 18th century. According to Foucault, the most prominent therapeutic technique instead became to confront patients with a healthy sound will and orthodox passions, ideally embodied by the physician.
It was thought the confrontation would lead not only to bring the illness into broad daylight by its resistance, but also to the victory of the sound will and the renunciation of the disturbed will.
We must apply a perturbing method, to break the spasm by means of the spasm We must subjugate the whole character of some patients, subdue their transports, break their pride, while we must stimulate and encourage the others Esquirol, J. Foucault also argued that the increasing internment of the "mentally ill" the development of more and bigger asylums had become necessary not just for diagnosis and classification but because an enclosed place became a requirement for a treatment that was now understood as primarily the contest of wills, a question of submission and victory.
The effect of this shift then served to inflate the power of the physician relative to the patient, correlated with the rapid rise of internment asylums and forced detention. And that by the end of the 19th century, psychiatrists often had little power in the overrun asylum system, acting mainly as administrators who rarely attended to patients, in a system where therapeutic ideals had turned into mindless institutional routines.
Those critiques occurred at a time when physicians had not yet achieved hegemony through psychiatry, however, so there was no single, unified force to oppose. For example, Daniel Defoe , the author of Robinson Crusoe , had previously argued for more government oversight of "madhouses" and for due process prior to involuntary internment.
Throughout, the class nature of mental hospitals , and their role as agencies of control, were well recognized. And the new psychiatry was partially challenged by two powerful social institutions — the church and the legal system. These trends have been thematically linked to the later 20th century anti-psychiatry movement. Practitioners criticized mental hospitals for failure to conduct scientific research and adopt the modern therapeutic methods such as nonrestraint.
Together with lay reformers and social workers, neurologists formed the National Association for the Protection of the Insane and the Prevention of Insanity. However, when the lay members questioned the competence of asylum physicians to even provide proper care at all, the neurologists withdrew their support and the association floundered.
Beers campaigned to improve the plight of individuals receiving public psychiatric care, particularly those committed to state institutions, publicizing the issues in his book, A Mind that Found Itself In Germany there were similar movements which used the term "Antipsychiatrie".
To Artaud, imagination was reality. Much influenced by the Dada and surrealist enthusiasms of the day, he considered dreams , thoughts and visions no less real than the "outside" world. Early s[ edit ] In the s several controversial medical practices were introduced, including inducing seizures by electroshock , insulin or other drugs or cutting parts of the brain apart lobotomy.
In the US, between and , over 50, lobotomy operations were performed in mental hospitals. But lobotomy was ultimately seen as too invasive and brutal. The Nazi programs were called Action T4 and Action 14f Even in incurable mentally ill ones suffering seriously from hallucinations and melancholic depressions and not being able to act, to a medical colleague I would ascript the right and in serious cases the duty to shorten — often for many years — the suffering" Bleuler, Eugen, "Die naturwissenschaftliche Grundlage der Ethik".
Meanwhile, most hospitalized mental patients received at best decent custodial care, and at worst, abuse and neglect. The psychoanalyst Jacques Lacan has been identified as an influence on later anti-psychiatry theory in the UK, and as being the first, in the s and 50s, to professionally challenge psychoanalysis to reexamine its concepts and to appreciate psychosis as understandable.
Critics disputed this and questioned how his descriptions linked to his practical work. The names that came to be associated with the anti-psychiatry movement knew of Lacan and acknowledged his contribution even if they did not entirely agree. In The Sane Society , Fromm wrote ""An unhealthy society is one which creates mutual hostility [and] distrust, which transforms man into an instrument of use and exploitation for others, which deprives him of a sense of self, except inasmuch as he submits to others or becomes an automaton" Thomas in West Yorkshire, England, where thousands of internees from Storthes Hall Hospital are buried in unmarked graves In the s new psychiatric drugs, notably the antipsychotic chlorpromazine , slowly came into use.
Although often accepted as an advance in some ways, there was opposition, partly due to serious adverse effects such as tardive dyskinesia , and partly due their "chemical straitjacket" effect and their alleged use to control and intimidate patients. There were widespread fears that it threatened individual rights and undermined moral responsibility. An early skirmish was over the Alaska Mental Health Bill , where the right wing protestors were joined by the emerging Scientology movement.
Behaviorists argued that mental disorder was a matter of learning not medicine; for example, Hans Eysenck argued that psychiatry "really has no role to play". The developing field of clinical psychology in particular came into close contact with psychiatry, often in opposition to its methods, theories and territories.
While most of its elements had precedents in earlier decades and centuries, in the s it took on a national and international character, with access to the mass media and incorporating a wide mixture of grassroots activist organizations and prestigious professional bodies. He spoke of having a goal of "non-psychiatry" as well as anti-psychiatry.
Their writings, along with others such as articles in the journal The Radical Therapist , were given the umbrella label "antipsychiatry" despite wide divergences in philosophy. This critical literature, in concert with an activist movement, emphasized the hegemony of medical model psychiatry, its spurious sources of authority, its mystification of human problems, and the more oppressive practices of the mental health system, such as involuntary hospitalisation, drugging, and electroshock".
It was sometimes seen as a transformative state involving an attempt to cope with a sick society. Laing had already become a media icon through bestselling books such as The Divided Self and The Politics of Experience discussing mental distress in an interpersonal existential context; Laing was somewhat less focused than his colleague Cooper on wider social structures and radical left wing politics, and went on to develop more romanticized or mystical views as well as equivocating over the use of diagnosis, drugs and commitment.
Although the movement originally described as anti-psychiatry became associated with the general counter-culture movement of the s, Lidz and Arieti never became involved in the latter. Franco Basaglia promoted anti-psychiatry in Italy and secured reforms to mental health law there. Laing, through the Philadelphia Association founded with Cooper in , set up over 20 therapeutic communities including Kingsley Hall , where staff and residents theoretically assumed equal status and any medication used was voluntary.
Non-psychiatric Soteria houses, starting in the United States, were also developed  as were various ex-patient-led services. Psychiatrist Thomas Szasz argued that " mental illness " is an inherently incoherent combination of a medical and a psychological concept. He opposed the use of psychiatry to forcibly detain, treat, or excuse what he saw as mere deviance from societal norms or moral conduct. As a libertarian , Szasz was concerned that such usage undermined personal rights and moral responsibility.
Although widely described as part of the main anti-psychiatry movement, Szasz actively rejected the term and its adherents; instead, in , he collaborated with Scientology to form the Citizens Commission on Human Rights. He argued that psychiatry was primarily a tool of social control, based historically on a "great confinement" of the insane and physical punishment and chains, later exchanged in the moral treatment era for psychological oppression and internalized restraint.
American sociologist Thomas Scheff applied labeling theory to psychiatry in in "Being Mentally Ill". Scheff argued that society views certain actions as deviant and, in order to come to terms with and understand these actions, often places the label of mental illness on those who exhibit them.
Certain expectations are then placed on these individuals and, over time, they unconsciously change their behavior to fulfill them. This raised questions as to whether the schizophrenia label and resulting involuntary psychiatric treatment could not have been similarly used in the West to subdue rebellious young people during family conflicts. New professional approaches were developed as an alternative or reformist complement to psychiatry. Social work , humanistic or existentialist therapies, family therapy , counseling and self-help and clinical psychology developed and sometimes opposed psychiatry.
Psychoanalysis was increasingly criticized as unscientific or harmful. Non-medical collaborative services were developed, for example therapeutic communities or Soteria houses. The psychoanalytically trained psychiatrist Szasz, although professing fundamental opposition to what he perceives as medicalization and oppressive or excuse-giving "diagnosis" and forced "treatment", was not opposed to other aspects of psychiatry for example attempts to "cure-heal souls", although he also characterizes this as non-medical.
Although generally considered anti-psychiatry by others, he sought to dissociate himself politically from a movement and term associated with the radical left-wing.
In a publication "Anti-psychiatry: The paradigm of a plundered mind", which has been described as an overtly political condemnation of a wide sweep of people, Szasz claimed Laing, Cooper and all of anti-psychiatry consisted of "self-declared socialists , communists , anarchists or at least anti- capitalists and collectivists ". This included those who felt they had been harmed by psychiatry or who felt that they could have been helped more by other approaches, including those compulsorily including via physical force admitted to psychiatric institutions and subjected to compulsory medication or procedures.
During the s, the anti-psychiatry movement was involved in promoting restraint from many practices seen as psychiatric abuses. The diagnosis was reclassified to better align it with medical understanding of the condition and to remove the stigma associated with the term disorder.
The critical element of gender dysphoria is the presence of clinically significant distress associated with the condition. Nevertheless, if we believe that by categorising homosexuality as a disease we have succeeded in removing it from the realm of moral judgement, we are in error. Anti-psychiatry came to challenge a " biomedical " focus of psychiatry defined to mean genetics , neurochemicals and pharmaceutic drugs.
There was also opposition to the increasing links between psychiatry and pharmaceutical companies , which were becoming more powerful and were increasingly claimed to have excessive, unjustified and underhand influence on psychiatric research and practice.
There was also opposition to the codification of, and alleged misuse of, psychiatric diagnoses into manuals, in particular the American Psychiatric Association, which publishes the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders.
Anti-psychiatry increasingly challenged alleged psychiatric pessimism and institutionalized alienation regarding those categorized as mentally ill. Schemes were developed to challenge stigma and discrimination, often based on a social model of disability ; to assist or encourage people with mental health issues to engage more fully in work and society for example through social firms , and to involve service users in the delivery and evaluation of mental health services.
However, those actively and openly challenging the fundamental ethics and efficacy of mainstream psychiatric practice remained marginalized within psychiatry, and to a lesser extent within the wider mental health community.
Three authors came to personify the movement against psychiatry, and two of these were practising psychiatrists. The initial and most influential of these was Thomas Szasz who rose to fame with his book The Myth of Mental Illness , although Szasz himself did not identify as an anti-psychiatrist.
Intellectual philosopher Michel Foucault challenged the very basis of psychiatric practice and cast it as repressive and controlling. The term "anti-psychiatry" was coined by David Cooper in Levine , considered part of the anti-psychiatry movement, have written widely on how society, culture, politics and psychology intersect. They have written extensively of the "embodied nature" of the individual in society, and the unwillingness of even therapists to acknowledge the obvious part played by power and financial interest in modern Western society.
They argue that feelings and emotions are not, as is commonly supposed, features of the individual, but rather responses of the individual to their situation in society. Even psychotherapy, they suggest, can only change feelings in as much as it helps a person to change the "proximal" and "distal" influences on their life, which range from family and friends, to the workplace, socio-economics, politics and culture.
Laing emphasized family nexus as a mechanism by which individuals become victimized by those around them, and spoke about a dysfunctional society.
Patients cannot be identified just by clinical interviews. What we are doing now is just like trying to diagnose diabetes mellitus without measuring blood sugar.
Cartwright identified what he called drapetomania, an ailment that caused slaves to be possessed by a desire for freedom and a want to escape In , psychiatrist Allen Frances said that "psychiatric diagnosis still relies exclusively on fallible subjective judgments rather than objective biological tests".
Mental disorders are not clearly natural processes whose detection is untarnished by the imposition of values, or human interpretation. It is unclear whether they should be conceived as abstractions that exist in the world apart from the individual persons who experience them, and thus instantiate them. Cartwright diagnosed some slaves with drapetomania, a mental illness in which the slave possessed an irrational desire for freedom and a tendency to try to escape.
This example indicates the probability for not only cultural bias but also confirmation bias and bias blind spot in psychiatric diagnosis and psychiatric beliefs[ citation needed ]. It has been argued by philosophers like Foucault that characterizations of "mental illness" are indeterminate and reflect the hierarchical structures of the societies from which they emerge rather than any precisely defined qualities that distinguish a "healthy" mind from a "sick" one.
Furthermore, if a tendency toward self-harm is taken as an elementary symptom of mental illness, then humans, as a species, are arguably insane in that they have tended throughout recorded history to destroy their own environments, to make war with one another, etc. Wahret Eure heiligsten Diagnosen! Protect your sanctified diagnoses! The individuals included a graduate student, psychologists, an artist, a housewife, and two physicians, including one psychiatrist.
All eight individuals were admitted with a diagnosis of schizophrenia or bipolar disorder. Psychiatrists then attempted to treat the individuals using psychiatric medication.
All eight were discharged within 7 to 52 days. In a later part of the study , psychiatric staff were warned that pseudo-patients might be sent to their institutions, but none were actually sent.
Nevertheless, a total of 83 patients out of were believed by at least one staff member to be actors.
Antipsiquiatría: historia y conceptos de este movimiento